The Fed Will Not Stop The Coming Crash In U.S. Stocks

The largest and most dangerous misconception in the financial world today is that central banks have the ability to control the direction of markets. History has show with clear distinction this is not the case, but investor's minds continuously experience the "recency bias."

During gold's most recent cyclical bull rally (2008 to 2011) analysts put up a chart of the price of gold layered against the the Fed's balance sheet growth. They tracked with each other for three straight years, which made investors feel that gold's rally would always track side by side with the Fed's balance sheet.

We know now this did not occur as the Fed continued expanding its balance sheet through QE3 while gold experienced its second major cyclical decline of the current secular bull market. While the Fed's balance sheet impacts the fundamentals for gold's price direction, it cannot be used as direct causation for the short term movement in its price. 

To understand why we'll look a little further back in history. Gold bottomed in early 2001 at $250 and rose to $900 in 2008 during a period when the Fed was mostly raising interest rates and tightening monetary policy (2004 - 2007).

During gold's secular bear market decline from 1980 to 2000, the Fed was steadily lowering interest rates and loosening monetary policy.

Since the arrival of QE in early 2009 analysts have been tracking the S&P 500 against the Fed's balance sheet. This has once again created the myth that the Fed pushes U.S. stocks higher and guides them lower.

This myth has already proven itself to be untrue as the Fed began tapering (slowing reducing the size) of QE in late 2013 and ended the program in October 2014. Stocks have risen steadily throughout this process and are currently sitting at all time record highs as I type this morning.

Even with this recent evidence available that stocks have already diverged from the Fed, investors cling to the notion that if the stock market begins to fall the Fed will step in with a new QE program and instantly reverse the price decline. As I said at the outset, this belief is the most dangerous assumption that permeates within the minds of investors today.

Because we are currently sitting at 0.0% interest rates the only possible way for the Fed to ease is with QE, which can be thought of as bringing rates to negative levels. The size of QE programs has become the new Fed fund rates in the perverse financial world we live in today.

So the question is, if U.S. stocks were to fall (which most people believe is now impossible to begin with), and the Fed were to begin lowering rates downward into negative territory (using QE), would they be able to instantly stop a market decline? Let's take a quick walk through history....

The 1920's run in stock prices peaked at the very end of 1929. When the market began to roll over and decline the Fed began cutting rates on February 11, 1930. The market would then go on to decline by 90% over the next two years through the rate cuts.

When the market peaked in 2000 after the greatest run in market history from 1980 to 2000, the Fed began cutting rates a few months later on January 3, 2001. The NASDAQ would go on to decline 80% from its peak through the rate cuts.

The Fed began cutting interest rates on September 18, 2007, two months before the U.S. stock market would hit its all time high. They would continue cutting rates for the next two years, bringing them all the way down to 0%. During that time the market declined by over 50% through the rate cuts.

Correlation equals causation only when charts line up for a brief period in history. The human mind acts as a problem solving machine that always looks for the simplest and fastest possible answer to any problem that presents itself so it can move on and begin solving the next one. The mantra that the Fed will always step in to save the markets solves this problem in investor's mind. They can comfortable put their life savings into U.S. stock index funds and move on to something else in their life.

In the past I have compared the psychological state of mind of investors living in Japan (recently experienced a 25 year decline in stock prices) to investors living in the United States (recently experienced the greatest 33 year rise in history and currently sitting at all time highs).

I live in the United States so I can live, breath and take in the almost religious belief that stocks will always move higher in the long run. Americans leave school and then put their hard earned money into U.S. stock 401ks for the duration of their entire working years. Everyone around them does it, the media and government tell them to do it, financial advisors tell them to do it, and it has worked brilliantly for as long as almost any American has been working in the United States (no one remembers the 1970's today).

If you showed the chart below to an average American and told them it was anything except for U.S. stocks, they would be most likely terrified of the future price potential of the asset. If you showed this chart to a Japanese citizen you would probably make them cry if you asked them enter the market with a portion of their savings. It would appear, even to the most casual viewer, we are in the final stages of the third bubble in the last 15 years (this chart is dated, the S&P has rocked up to 2090 as I write this morning)

Investors understand and believe the previous two bubbles and crashes were driven by overly accommodative Fed policy. However, after 5 years of the most accomodative monetary policy in Federal Reserve history, with stocks sitting at all time record high prices, and almost every valuation metric resting at all time record high levels, investors believe this time is different.

I'm betting that this time is not different, and I'm willing to wait for as long as it takes for prices to move back into realistic historical valuations before entering. There are just too many other cheap investment opportunities around the world to invest in. If you live in the United States, take a moment to review your portfolio before entering the new year. If U.S. stock funds are your largest investment, you are sitting in the most expensive asset class on the planet.

For more see: What If The Stock Market Fell & Did Not Recover?


  1. "This myth has already proven itself to be untrue as the Fed ended QE at the end of 2013 and stocks have risen steadily throughout 2014 (sitting at all time record highs as I type this morning)."

    I am a fan of your site, but QE3 didn't end until October 2014.

    1. You are correct. I should have been more clear in what I was trying to say. They began tapering QE (tightening monetary policy) in late 2013. I changed it to say: "This myth has already proven itself to be untrue as the Fed began tapering (slowing reducing the size) of QE in late 2013 and ended the program in October 2014."

      Thank you.

  2. This is a terrible article.

    1. Gold stopped tracing QE because the Fed manipulated the price downwards. Grant Williams in Things that go hmmm... has explained this in great detail. By all rights gold should be MUCH higher.

    2. You forget that this time is different. This time central banks are printing trillions and they are using that money to a) directly buy stocks and b) lending it to corporations at zirp and they are using that cash for buy backs

    3. Money managers can see this and they pile in behind because it makes no sense to Fight the Fed.

    Of course this cannot go on forever. But it can go on for a lot longer than you think. Because the central banks can print unlimited money and for them there is no stopping because stopping means the markets have a heart attack

  3. Sorry, but I believe this time is indeed different.

    I have been beliving that this time would not be different for the past 2 years (since mid-2013), and I have been crushed again and again and again and again. And again. And again.
    I keep being crushed.
    The S&P 500 will not stop its course.

    Because it can't.

    Because the Fed is too terrified now. They are so afraid of a drop.
    They will pour vast amount of money. That's all that they have left.
    Let's not talk about a tax hike. This won't happen. Never.

    Please, read my sentence above if you don't understand it.

    Of course, it will end badly, and of course, they won't be able to control the crash.

    Just not this year....

    Not this year.

    They need to mess things up a lot more before it happens.

    So, in essence, I agree with the comment just before mine : it will end very very badly, just not in 2015...


Post a Comment